LATEST POSTING
With this blog, Economics in the Rear-View Mirror (ninth anniversary celebrated on May 8, 2024), I am sharing a growing selection (here is the list of 1824) of artifacts mostly related to the undergraduate and graduate teaching of economics in the United States from the 1870s through the 1970s. Thanks to an inaugural research grant from the Institute for New Economic Thinking (INET), I have spent significant time in the Harvard, Columbia, Chicago, M.I.T. and Yale archives as well as in the Hoover Institution Archive and at the Duke University Economists’ Papers Archive. I have also visited the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, the Johns Hopkins University Archives, and the Library of Congress. Other artifacts I have transcribed have been trawled from on-line archives from other universities as well as archive.org and hathitrust.org. I do hope that the material provided here helps the academic community of historians of economics, practicing or in-training.
I retired from Freie Universität Berlin on July 31, 2018. My farewell lecture was given July 4, 2018. During the academic years 2018/19 through 2021/22 I taught at Bard College Berlin. Currently, I am a free-range scholar.
Here an ancient, short video interview that introduces me and my original INET project. A work-in-progress interview podcast about what I am up to in this blog was conducted by Reinhard Schumacher in the history of economics podcast series Ceteris Never Paribus.
For newcomers to Economics in the Rear-View Mirror, here are a few of my Curator’s Favorites.
- A 30 typewritten page list of proposed course paper topics with suggested references at the dawn of the age of Keynesian macroeconomics. From John H. Williamson and Seymour E. Harris’ course on money, banking and commercial crises at Harvard, 1938-39.
- The pastiche of Raphael’s “The School of Athens” for the “Chicago School of Economics 1972” by Roger Vaughan with identifications for the economists drawn.
- Thomas Schelling’s 1970 Harvard course “Conflict, Coalition and Strategy”. Reading list and final exam.
- From MIT in 1976: the complete script for the second-year class’s legendary skit “The Wizard of E52-383c”, featuring a photograph of none other than Paul Krugman playing Paul Samuelson in this Wizard of Oz parody.
- Links to over 98% of the items in the bibliographies in the first edition of Frank W. Taussig’s Principles of Economics (1911).
- Twenty years of graduate economic history exams at Harvard 1930-1949. Courses taught by Edwin F. Gay and Abbott P. Usher.
- Edwin F. Gay’s ca. 90 item short bibliography of English, French, German and U.S. economic history “for serious students”. Links to all but one of the items and multi-volume works completely linked as well.
- Complete links to the works cited by Moritz Kaufmann in the forward to his 1879 book: Utopias; or, Schemes of Social Improvement from Sir Thomas More to Karl Marx.
- Links to 116 books of the 120 published in the distinguished Social Science Series by Swan Sonnenschein (London) 1884-1912.
- Paul Krugman’s M.I.T. course “Principles of Economics” (1998). Reading assignments, lecture slides, problems sets and exams with answers.
- Historical and Practical Political Economy. Outline of Lectures to the Students of the School of Political Science of Columbia College ca. 1891-92. An eight page printed syllabus for a course taught by Richmond Mayo-Smith, now with links to over 95% of the assigned reading.
- Henry Schultz’s reading list (most items linked!) for the mathematical economics course he taught at Chicago in 1935.
- Thomas Nixon Carver’s reading list (all items linked!) for his course at Harvard “Economic Theory in the Nineteenth Century”, 1900-01.
- Linked reading list for the history and theory of money taught by Sidney Sherwood, 1891-92.
- Laughlin’s List from 1887 with links to publications he recommended for every economics teacher’s library.
- Reading assignments for Frank W. Taussig’s economic theory course from 1923-24 (with links!) extracted from Frank W. Fetter’s student notes for the course.
- Fully-linked list of 28 Popular Economic Tracts from 1880-1891 published by the Society for Political Education.
- Reading list (almost completely linked) to William Fellner’s History of Economic Thought course taught at Harvard during the academic year 1950-51.
- Guide to the Cambridge University Moral Sciences Tripos from 1891. An entire curriculum with major works to be read in psychology, philosophy, and political economy. Includes many links to the Greatest Hits from before turn of the 20th century.
- Undergraduate and graduate labor economics at Harvard, late 1920s. Trade-unionism was the focus of the undergraduate course. Unemployment added to the graduate course. Links to almost everything.
- Back in the day when sociology and economics were still well-behaved siblings, Franklin H. Giddings taught a graduate course in sociology at Bryn Mawr in 1893. This post provides links to nearly all the fifty or so items listed in Giddings’ Sociology Readings.
- The 1902-03 iteration of Thomas Nixon Carver’s Principles of Sociology at Harvard was co-taught with William Z. Ripley. The complete linked reading list and the final exam questions for the course.
- Exam questions for the three political economy courses taught in 1879-80 at Harvard. Links to the relevant sections or pages of John Stuart Mill’s Principles of Political Economy make this post particularly valuable.
Portraits of economists are not hard to find on the internet. I have added a special collection that features pictures of Economists Wearing Bowties for no other reason than it allows me another excuse to prepare light-hearted fare for visitors to Economics in the Rear-View Mirror. To complement the bowties collection, we also have the Economists Wearing Jewelry Collection. A new feature page was added in October 2022 of colorized photos of economists we have seen in black and white images.
A special service for visitors interested in scans of early editions of important earlier works in economics: a link to “my” Economics Rare Book Reading Room. It is a collection in-progress, so worth returning to from time to time.
Links to books published by Swan Sonnenschein (London) during the quarter century bracketing the turn from the nineteenth to the twentieth century.
For links to 20th century economics books, we also have a Twentieth Century Economics Library.
Special pages for Harvard and Radcliffe Ph.D.’s through 1929 and Chicago Ph.D.’s in Economics through 1926.
Links to resources concerning the higher education of women in general as well as in economics.
Scroll down if you would like to subscribe to this blog; new content will be announced by tweet @irwincollier; or visit the outpost on Facebook.
32 replies on “Introduction to Economics in the Rear-view Mirror”
Irwin, so glad to see the website is up!
Welcome aboard Jennifer! Glad to have a full-time historian looking into the rear-view mirror over my shoulder.
As an Independent Scholar interested in both archives and economic history, I am glad to find this resources!
So happy to hear! Welcome aboard and enjoy the company of the jolly historians of economics. Your comments, insight and advice are most welcome too.
I just ran across this wonderful video interview with Solow
https://compton.mit.edu/robert-solow
As a retired economist very interested in economic history, I am happy to find this blog.
Thanks for the feedback. A couple of years from retirement myself, providing content to this blog is the plan from here on out.
Thanks Iwin! For those few of us students under the German Historical School method (Tallinn University of Technology) this is an invaluable repository. I know that my professor Erik Reinert (Cornell, Harvard, St Gallen) would be interested and I’ll let him know about your website.
You are most welcome! As coincidence would have it, I just posted a link to the Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin’s first edition of Carl Menger’s “Die Irrthümer des Historismus in der deutschen nationalökonomie” from 1884 on my “Rare Book Reading Room” page. Needn’t worry, both sides of the debate will get their place on that page…Cheers.
I’m very lucky to find your resource! Thank you Professor!
I am Steven from China, who was insipred by Armen.Alchian’s book and start to love the economics.
This website is unbelievable precious!!!
Thank you Professor.
But since the UCLA is also an important place for the conomics,
I wish to see some stuff from the Alchian, Jack.Hirshleifer…etc.
Thanks a lot.
Steven
15/1/2018
Thanks Steven. UCLA economics is indeed important. I began my research on the training of economists with an artificial end-point of ca. 1950 (i.e. to just before I was born). In the meantime I have gradually relaxed the window to ca. 1970 (before I had much contact with university economics). In any event, I have not had the opportunity yet to explore the archives at UC Berkeley or UCLA. For 1950-1970 I really need to do more, but 1870-1950 is not exactly overstudied so it will take me some time to get there. Hope to get there soon though.
this is intersting pagi.
Dear Irwin Collier,
I regularly read your postings, but now I wonder if you can help me in a new piece of research I am starting. I am interested in the History of Econometrics and want to look at the work of Henry Schultz at the University of Chicago. Is there anything that you have posted that would help me in my research?
Thanks,
Jim Thomas (LSE)
Dear Jim Thomas:
https://www.irwincollier.com/tag/schultzh/ gives you all the posts where I tagged Schultz. Hope there is something there that helps.
Sincerely,
Bud Collier
What a treasure trove! Unsurprising you would be the source/curator.
I’m wandering about from topic to name to place in my usual intersectional approach. Random juxtapositions generate more questions, hard to stop.
Love from Minnesota,
Lucy
Dear Irwin,
I found your Economics in the Rear-View Mirror web site while doing some research on Elmo Hohman.
Your work as an archaeologist of the history of economic thought is an invaluable resource.
Thank you.
Mark
Many thanks!
Irwin, what a wonderful webpage! I just read the post on German universities 1901! A joy to read, and amazingly, some descriptions seem apt, even today! I hope you’re doing well.
Hi Christine, thanks for feedback! The post has proved to have attracted thousands of visitors after my distinguished colleague Tyler Cowen gave it a thumbs up. Stay tuned, about to put up a couple of money and banking exams of your Dad. — Bud
I found your posting on Elizabeth Lane Waterman, which is wrong about her death date. You give the date of August 18, 1958, which was the death date of her ex-husband. Elizabeth died on October 10, 1973. The Boston Globe included several obituaries for her at that time, and she published in 1968 A Primer on the Economics of Consumption.
Many thanks for the correction. I trusted an ancestry.com family tree entry without doing due dilegence. But what is nice about having a website, it is not difficult to correct a post.
Bud: A contribution to “Economists Wearing Jewelry” Collection.
https://static.cambridge.org/binary/version/id/urn:cambridge.org:id:binary-alt:20170408222305-38181-mediumThumb-S1365100504030202fig001g.jpg?pub-status=live
Mr. Collier, I imported your amazing logo in a video I stitched together for the Center for Spatial and Textual Analysis once.
Flattered to find a page archived at https://web.archive.org/web/20220707065318/https://cesta.stanford.edu/news/dh-community-engagement-resources-tuesday
Thank you UNA/JFK-I, FU-Berlin alumna!
yay!
I have been reading many of your posts and was delighted to find you have been examining Green’s book of American Black PhD’s up to 1946. The puzzle of the entry for W. G. Henry for a PhD in 1918 struck me as well, and I am so glad you sorted that out. I cite this piece and your piece on Bradford Brazeal in my SSRN paper Racism, Segregation, Acceptance: American Economics and Black Labor Studies, 1885-1965.
Having profited from your research I am so glad that you have found something of use for your work. Further example of how the internet can be used to create a big virtual faculty lounge.
Thanks for the blog of amazing information!
https://www.irwincollier.com/bryn-mawr-economics-ph-d-alumna-marion-parris-1908/
found a typo for the birthyear: it should be 1879 instead of 1897
thanks so much!
A Google on Henry Raymond Mussey led to your blog post. I had read of Mussey’s unconventional wedding in a fascinating book that is reproduced on Project Gutenberg- “14000 Miles a Carriage and Two Women.” https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/71527
Well down in Chapter XVI is an account of the wedding from the Boston Transcript, July 6, 1905
This is fantastic!. Thanks for sharing that. Definitely worth a blogpost!