Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Public Finance

Harvard. Exam for undergraduate public finance. Bullock, 1905-1906

Charles Jesse Bullock compressed his two semester public finance sequence at Harvard that was pitched to graduates and advanced undergraduates in 1904-05 into a single semester for undergraduates in the following academic year. This compression and “dumbing down” [?] resulted in a significant increase in enrollment. Who knows, maybe he even lowered the curve for grading?

__________________________

Exams from the two semester sequence in public finance (1904-05)

1904-05. Introduction to Public Finance (post includes two obituaries for Bullock)

1904-05. Theory and Methods of Taxation

__________________________

Course Enrollment
1905-06

Economics 7 2hf. Asst. Professor Bullock. — Public Finance considered with special reference to the Theory and Methods of Taxation.

Total 137: 13 Seniors, 54 Juniors, 55 Sophomores, 4 Freshman, 11 Others.

Source: Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1905-1906, p. 72.

__________________________

ECONOMICS 7
Year-end Examination, 1905-06

  1. Discuss the history of federal expenditures in the United States since 1860.
  2. Discuss the past and the present policy of the United States with respect to its public lands.
  3. Give an account of the present status of the municipal ownership movement in the United States.
  4. Discuss the proposition that income is the normal source of taxation.
  5. What is your opinion concerning the justice of progressive taxation?
  6. What was decided in the income tax decisions of 1895?
  7. Give a detailed account of the present method of taxing personal property in Massachusetts.
  8. Compare the general corporation tax of Massachusetts with that of Pennsylvania.
  9. Write an account of the present status of the inheritance tax in the American commonwealths.
  10. Write a history of federal taxation in the United States from 1789 to the present day.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University, Examination Papers 1873-1915. Box 8, Bound volume: Examination Papers, 1906-07; Papers Set for Final Examinations in History, Government, Economics,…,Music in Harvard College (June, 1906), p. 32.

Image Source: Illustration by Louis M. Glackens in Puck, April 8, 1908. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/ppmsca.26261

Categories
Chicago Economics Programs

Chicago. Program of Political Economy. Thick course descriptions. 1904-1905

Broschures that advertise economics departments are often useful summaries of the “order of battle” for their educational and research missions. The Chicago Department of Political Economy was about a dozen years in business when this programme, transcribed below, was published. The course descriptions are somewhat thicker than are typically found in full university catalogs that must share space for the many divisions and schools that constitute the larger institution. 

Incidentally, the copy of the printed programme that was transcribed for this post was found in an archival box of material dealing with graduate studies in the Division of History, Government, and Economics at Harvard University. Then as now, prudence demands keeping an eye on your competition. 

______________________________

Related Posts on the Early Years
of the Department of Political Economy
of the University of Chicago

First detailed announcement of Political Economy program at the University of Chicago, 1892.

General Regulations for the degree of Ph.D. at the University of Chicago, 1903.

Twenty-Fifth Anniversary of the Department of Political Economy, 1916.

______________________________

CONSPECTUS OF COURSES,
1904-1905.
POLITICAL ECONOMY.

All courses are Mj [major] unless otherwise indicated.

SUMMER AUTUMN WINTER SPRING
1 Principles of Political
  Economy
(Hill) 9:00
1 Principles of Political Economy
a (Hill) 8:30
b (Davenport) 12:00
1 Principles of Political Economy
(Hill) 12:00
2 Principles of Political Economy Con’d
a (Hill) 8:30
b (Davenport) 12:00
2 Principles of Political Economy Con’d
(Davenport) 12:00
3 Economic and Social History
(Morris) 2:00
3 Economic and Social History
(Morris) 12:00
4 History of Commerce
(Morris) 12:00
5B Commercial Geography for Teachers
(Goode) 1:30
5 Commercial Geography
(Mr. —) 8:30
8 Mathematical Problems of Insurance
(Epsteen)
6 Modern Industries
(Mr. —) 11:00
7 Insurance
(Davenport) 8:30
[9 Law of Insurance]
(Bigelow)
10 Accounting
(Mr. — ) 11:00
11 Special Problems of Accounting
(Several Experts)
12 Modern Business Methods
(Clow) 8:00
12 Modern Business Methods
(Mr. —) 9:30
20 History of Political Economy
(Veblen) 11:00
21 Scope and Method
(Veblen) 11:00
22 Finance
(Davenport) 8:30
24 Financial History of the United States
(Cummings) 8:00
24 Financial History of the United States
(Cummings) 2:00
23 Tariff Reciprocity and Shipping
(Cummings) 9:30
26 American Agriculture
(Hill) 10:30
26 American Agriculture
(Hill) 10:30
25 Economic Factors in Civilization
(Veblen) 11:00
27 Colonial Economics
(Morris) 9:30
40 Value
(Davenport) 8:30
41 Labor and Capital
(Laughlin) 12:00
44 Socialism
(Veblen) 9:30
46 Trade Unions
(Cummings)
9:30
45 Industrial Combinations (Veblen) 9:30 43 Economics of Workingmen
(Cummings) 9:30
46 Trades Unions
(Cummings) 12:00
50 Money
(Laughlin) 12:00
51 Banking
(Mr. —) 8:30
50 Money
(Laughlin) 12:00
[52 Advertising]

53 Practical Banking
(Mr. — ) 8:30

60 Railways
(Hill) 2:00
61 Railway Rates
(Meyer) 2:00
62 Government Ownership (I)
(Meyer) 2:00
63 Government Ownership (II)
(Meyer) 2:00
64 American Competition
(Meyer) 3:00
70 Statistics
(Cummings) 8:30
71 Statistics of Wages
(Cummings) 12:00
80 Seminar
(Laughlin)
81 Seminar
(Laughlin)
[82 Seminar
(Laughlin)]

______________________________

THE DEPARTMENT
OF POLITICAL ECONOMY.

OFFICERS OF INSTRUCTION.

JAMES LAURENCE LAUGHLIN, Ph.D., Professor and Head of the Department of Political Economy.

THORSTEIN B. VEBLEN, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

WILLIAM HILL, A.M., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

JOHN CUMMINGS, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

HENRY RAND HATFIELD, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

HERBERT JOSEPH DAVENPORT, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

HUGO RICHARD MEYER, A.B., Assistant Professor of Political Economy.

ROBERT MORRIS, A.B, LL.B., Instructor in Political Economy.

F. R. CLOW, Professor of Political Economy, State Normal School, Oshkosh, Wis. (Summer Quarter, 1904).

FELLOWS.
1904-1905.

EDITH ABBOTT, A.B
EARL DEAN HOWARD, Ph.B.
WILLIAM JETT LAUCK, A.B.

INTRODUCTORY.

The work of the department is intended to provide, by symmetrically arranged courses of instruction, a complete training in the various branches of economics, beginning with elementary work and passing by degrees to the higher work of investigation. A chief aim of the instruction will be to teach methods of work, to foster a judicial spirit, and to cultivate an attitude of scholarly independence. (1) The student may pass, in the various courses of instruction, over the whole field of economics. (2) When fitted, he will be urged to pursue some special investigation. (3) For the encouragement of research and the training of properly qualified teachers of economics, Fellowships in Political Economy have been founded. (4) To provide a means of communication between investigators and the public, a review, entitled the Journal of Political Economy, has been established, to be edited by the officers of instruction in the department; while (5) larger single productions will appear in a series of bound volumes to be known as Economic Studies of the University of Chicago. [For links see below]

FELLOWSHIPS.

The Fellowships here offered by the Department of Political Economy are independent of those offered by the allied departments of History, Political Science, or Sociology.

Appointments will be made only on the basis of marked ability in economic studies and of capacity for investigation of a high character. It is a distinct advantage to candidates to have been one year in residence at the University. Candidates for these Fellowships should send to the President of the University a record of their previous work and distinctions, degrees and past courses of study, with copies of their written or printed work in economics. Applications should be sent in not later than March 1 of each year Appointments will be made during the first week of April.

Fellows are forbidden to give private tuition, and may be called upon for assistance in the work of teaching in the University or for other work; but in no case will they be expected or permitted to devote more than one sixth of their time to such service.

In addition, one Graduate Scholarship, yielding a sum sufficient to cover the annual tuition fees, is awarded to the best student in economics just graduated from the Senior Colleges; and a similar Scholarship is given to the student graduating from the Junior Colleges who passes the best examination at a special test.

CANDIDACY FOR HIGHER DEGREES.

Graduate courses are provided for training and research in subjects such as wages, money, agriculture, socialism, industrial combinations, statistics, demography, finance, and the like. Specialization may be carried on in many parts of the field, under special direction in the Seminar, whereby each student receives a personal appointment for one hour a week. The work is so adjusted as to form an organized scheme leading by regular stages to productive results suitable for publication.

Candidates for the degree of A.M. will not be permitted to offer elementary courses in Political Economy as part of the work during the year’s residence. The work of students taking Political Economy as a secondary subject for the degree of A.M., should include (1) the general principles of economics (as contained in Courses 1 and 2, or an equivalent); (2) the history of Political Economy; and (3) the scope and method of Political Economy.

The work of candidates for the degree of Ph.D., taking Political Economy as a secondary subject, should include, in addition to the above requirements for the degree of A.M., on (1) Public Finance, and (2) on some descriptive subject as, e.g., Money, or Tariff, or Railways, etc.; and the examination will be more searching than that for the degree of A.M.

In all cases candidates should consult early with the heads of the departments within which their Major and Minor subjects are taken.

Before being admitted to candidacy for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, in case Political Economy is chosen as the principal subject, the student must furnish satisfactory evidence to the head of the department that he has been well prepared in the following courses (or their equivalents at other institutions): History of Europe in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries (History 11); Europe in the Nineteenth Century (History 12); Later Constitutional Period of the United States; the Civil War and the Reconstruction (History 18); Comparative National Government (Political Science 11); Federal Constitutional Law of the United States (Political Science 21); Elements of International Law (Political Science 41); and Introduction to Sociology (Sociology 72).

PUBLICATIONS

As a means of communication between investigators and the public, the University issues quarterly the Journal of Political Economy, the first number of which appeared in December of 1892. Contributions to its pages will be welcomed from writers outside as well as inside the University the aim being not only to give investigators a place of record for their researches, but also to further in every possible way the interests of economic study throughout the country. The Journal will aim to lay more stress than existing journals upon articles dealing with practical economic questions. The editors will welcome articles from writers of all shades of economic opinion, reserving only the privilege of deciding as to merit and timeliness.

Longer investigations, translations of important books needed for American students, reprints of scarce works, and collections of materials will appear in bound volumes in a series of Economic Studies of the University of Chicago, of which the following have already been issued:

No. I. The Science of Finance, by Gustav Cohn. Translated by Dr. T. B. Veblen, 1895, 8vo, pp. xi+800. Price, $3.50.

No. II. History of the Union Pacific Railway, by Henry Kirke White, 1895, 8vo, pp. 132. Price, $1.50.

No. III. The Indian Silver Currency, by Karl Ellstaetter. Translated by J. Laurence Laughlin, 1896, 8vo, pp. 116. Price, $1.25.

No. IV. State Aid to Railways in Missouri, by John Wilson Million, 1897, 8vo, pp. 264. Price, $1.75.

No. V. History of the Latin Monetary Union, by Henry Parker Willis, 1901, 8vo, pp. ix + 332. Price $2.00.

No. VI. The History of the Greenbacks, with Special Reference to the Economic Consequences of Their Issue, by Wesley Clair Mitchell, 1903, 8vo, pp. xiv + 500. Price, $4.00, net.

No. VII. Legal Tender: A Study in English and American Monetary History, by Sophonisba P. Breckinridge, 1903, 8vo, pp. xvii + 180. Price, $1.50, net.

LIBRARY FACILITIES.

In the suite of class-rooms occupied by the department will be found the Economic Library. Its selection has been made with great care, in order to furnish not only the books needed for the work of instruction in the various courses, but especially collections of materials for the study of economic problems. The University Library contains an unusually complete set of United States Documents, beginning with the First Congress. It is believed that ample provision has thus been made for the work of serious research. The work of the students will necessarily be largely carried on in the Economic Library where will also be found the past as well as the current numbers of all the European and American economic journals.

The combined library facilities of Chicago are exceptional. The Public Library, maintained by a large city tax, the Newberry Library, and the Crerar Library, with a fund of several millions of dollars, which has provided books on Political Economy, will enable the student to obtain material needed in the prosecution of detailed investigation.

SPECIAL ADVANTAGES.

For the convenience of those who wish to know the branches of economics in which especial advantages are offered by the department, attention is called to the new facilities afforded for specialization in several directions:

RAILWAYS.

Apart from the fundamental training in the general economic field, a new and exceptional series of advanced courses in the economic side of railways has been provided. It is believed that no such extended and useful courses have ever been offered before on this subject. Beginning with the usual general course on railway transportation, four new courses are presented for advanced students.

LABOR AND CAPITAL.

In view of the pressing importance of questions touching upon the rewards of labor and capital, an exceptional arrangement of courses dealing both with the underlying principles and the practical movements of the day have been prepared upon new and extended lines.

MONEY.

Opportunities for specialization in the field of money and banking have been offered in the past, but new courses have been organized in order to permit a more thorough study in these subjects, both theoretical and practical, than has ever been possible before.

LABORATORY FOR STATISTICAL RESEARCH WORK.

The University has equipped a laboratory for statistical research work in which students are given training in the collection and tabulation of statistical data, as well as in the scientific construction of charts, and diagrams. The object of the work is to familiarize students with practical methods employed in government bureaus, municipal, state, and federal, in the United States and in other countries, and in private agencies of sociological and economic investigation. Men are trained to enter the service of such bureaus or agencies of social betterment as statisticians, capable of undertaking any work requiring expert statistical service. The Departments of Political Economy and of Sociology co-operate in the direction of statistical investigations.

COURSES OF INSTRUCTION.
Summer Quarter, 1904—Spring Quarter, 1905.

M=Minor course a single course for six weeks.
Mj=Major course=a single course for twelve weeks

GENERAL.

The courses are classified as follows:

Group 1, Introductory and Commercial: Courses 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.

Group II, Advanced Business Courses: Courses 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12.

Group III, General Economic Field: Courses 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 29-30, 31-32.

Group IV, Labor and Capital: Courses 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47.

Group V, Money and Banking: Courses 50, 51, 52, 53, 54.

Group VI, Railways: Courses 60, 61, 62, 63, 64.

Group VII, Statistics: Courses 70, 71, 72.

Group VIII, Seminars: Courses 80, 81, 82.

Students are advised to begin the study of economics not later than the first year of their entrance into the Senior Colleges; and students of high standing, showing special aptitude for economic study, may properly take the Courses of Group I in the last year of the Junior Colleges.

For admission to the courses of Groups II and III, a prerequisite is the satisfactory completion of Courses 1 and 2 in the department, or an equivalent. Course 1 is not open to students who do not intend to continue the work of Course 2.

JUNIOR COLLEGE COURSES.
Group I. — Introductory and Commercial. 

1 and 2. Principles of Political Economy. — Exposition of the laws of modern Political Economy.

Course 1.

Mj. Summer Quarter; 8:00. Assistant Professor Hill.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 2 sections, 8:30 and 12:00. Assistant Professors Hill and Davenport.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 12:00. Assistant Professor Hill.

Course 2.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 2 sections: 8:30 and 12:00. Assistant Professors Hill and Davenport.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 12:00. Assistant Professor Davenport.

Courses 1 and 2 together are designed to give the students an acquaintance with the working principles of modern Political Economy. The general drill in the principles cannot be completed in one quarter; and the department does not wish students to elect Course 1 who do not intend to continue the work in Course 2. Descriptive and practical subjects are introduced as the principles are discussed, and the field is only half covered in Course 1. Those who do not take both 1 and 2 are not prepared to take any advanced courses.

  1. Economic and Social History. — It is thought that the course may be of advantage to students of Political Science and History by giving them a view of the economic side of the social and political life of the past one hundred and fifty years. Special attention is devoted to the study of the economic effects of the Colonial System; the American and French Revolutions; the “industrial revolution;” the effects of invention and the new transportation upon the movement and grouping of population; the discoveries of the precious metals in North America, South America, Africa, and Australia; slavery, the Civil War, the new South, and the redistribution of industries in the United States; the progress of Great Britain since the repeal of the Corn Laws; and the recent development of German industry.

Mj. Autumn 2:00 and Spring Quarters; 12:00.
Mr. Morris.

Course 3 is required of all students in the College of Commerce and Administration.

  1. History of Commerce. — A brief general survey of ancient medieval and modern commerce. Consideration of the articles of commerce, the market places, the trade routes, methods of transportation, and the causes which promoted and retarded the growth of commerce in the principal commercial nations.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 12:00. Mr. Morris.

  1. Commercial Geography. — A study of the various countries and their chief products; the effect of soil, climate, and geographical situation in determining national industries and international trade, commercial routes, seaports; the location of commercial and industrial centers; exports and imports; the character, importance, and chief sources of the principal articles of foreign trade.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 8:30.
Mr. ———

Required of all students in the
College of Commerce and Administration.

  1. Modern Industries. — This elementary course, requiring no previous study of economics, examines the present organization of some of the leading industries. Study is made of the internal business organization, the processes of manufacture, the effect of inventions, etc. Emphasis will be placed on the manufactures of the United States.
    The class will visit a number of large industrial establishments in and near Chicago.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 11:00.
Mr. ———

SENIOR COLLEGES AND GRADUATE COURSES.
Group II. — Advanced Business Courses.
  1. Insurance. — This course will aim to cover those aspects of insurance important to the practical business man, and to serve at the same time as a descriptive and theoretical treatment adapted to the needs of students intending to specialize in the actuarial and legal aspect of the subject. The history and theory of insurance, the bearing of these on the different insurance relations of modern business, including accident, health, burial, suretyship, credit forms, and the like will be examined. Especial emphasis will, however, be given: (1) to Life Insurance, the various forms of organization, assessment, fraternal, stock, and mutual; the theory of rates, mortality, expense, reserve, and interest aspects; the different combinations of investment and mortality contracts, loan and surrender values, dividends, distribution periods; (2) to Fire Insurance, the various forms of business organization, the terms and conditions of the insurance contract, the different forms of hazard, and the competition and combination of rates therefor; the theory of reserves and co-insurance, and the problem of the valued policy laws; (3) the general principle of public supervision with regard to the different forms of insurance, and the wider question of public ownership.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 8:30.
Assistant Professor Davenport.

  1. The Mathematics of Insurance. — This course presupposes some acquaintance with the descriptive aspect of insurance. The course is devoted particularly to the mathematical principles of Life Insurance. The necessary elements of the theory are selected from the theories of probability, finite differences, and interpolation. Applications are made in particular to the following problems: The examination of the different mortality tables and the basing of mortality rates thereon; the loading of expenses and reserves and the variations of premiums, as affected by the prospective earnings of investments: the computation of total reserves; the fixation of loan and surrender values of paid-up insurance, whether by life or term extension; the computation of present and deferred annuities as affected by considerations of age, life, term, endowment, joint-life, and annuity policies.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 12:00.
Mr. Epsteen.

Prerequisite: Trigonometry and College Algebra
(Mathematical Courses 1, 2 or 1, 5 or 4, 5).
See Mathematics 9.

  1. Law of Insurance. — Insurable interest in various kinds of insurance and when it must exist; beneficiaries; the amounts recoverable and valued policies; representations; warranties; waiver and powers of agents; interpretation of phrases in policies; assignment of insurance.

Mj. Spring Quarter.
Assistant Professor Bigelow.

Text book: Wambaugh, Cases on Insurance.

  1. Accounting. — The interpretation of accounts viewed with regard to the needs of the business manager rather than those of the accountant: the formation and meaning of the balance sheet; the profit and loss statement and its relation to the balance sheet; the capital accounts, surplus, reserve, sinking funds; reserve funds, their use and misuse; depreciation accounts; other accounts appearing on credit side; assets; methods of valuation; confusing of assets and expenses; capital expenditures and operating expenses; capital assets, cash, and other reserves.

Prerequisite: The Course in Bookkeeping offered by the Department of Mathematics.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 11:00.
Mr. ———.

  1. Special Problems in Accounting.
    1. Bank accounting.
    2. The duties of an auditor; methods of procedure; practice; problems frequently met.
    3. Appraisal and Depreciation.
    4. Railway Accounting. A consideration of the principal features. Determination of the four main divisions of expense. The relation between capital expenditures and profit and loss.
    5. The Public Accountant. Legal regulations; duties and methods; constructive work in devising system of accounting to fit special needs. Practice in comparison of various systems. The advantages of various devices, loose-leaf and card systems; voucher system; cost keeping.

Mj. Spring Quarter.
Conducted by experts from Chicago institutions.

  1. Modern Business Methods. Corporation Finance. — Speculation, investment, exchange. The course aims to make clear to the student the meaning of the commercial and financial columns of current journals and to examine the economic significance of the business transactions thus reported. Attention is given among other things to the reports of the money market, the business on stock and produce exchanges, market quotations, the various forms of investment securities, and foreign exchange.

Summer Quarter; 11:30.
Mj. Spring Quarter; 9:30.
Professor Clow.

Group III — General Economic Field.
  1. History of Political Economy. — Lectures, Reading, and Reports. This course treats of the development of Political Economy as a systematic body of doctrine; of the formation of economic conceptions and principles, policies, and systems. The subject will be so treated as to show the continuity and systematic character of Political Economy as an intelligent explanation of economic facts. Both the history of topics and doctrines and that of schools and leading writers will be studied. Attention will be given to the commercial theories of the Mercantile System, the Physiocratic School, Adam Smith and his immediate predecessors, the English writers from Adam Smith to J. S. Mill, and the European and American writers of the nineteenth century. Selection will be made of those who have had great influence, and who have made marked contributions to Political Economy. The student will be expected to read prescribed portions of the great authors bearing on cardinal principles. It is hoped that in this way he will learn to see the consistency and relations of economic theories and to use the science as a whole, and not as a mere mass of arbitrary formulæ or dicta. A special feature of the work will be a thorough study of Adam Smith and of Ricardo.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 11:00.
Assistant Professor Veblen.

  1. Scope and Method of Political Economy. — The course treats of the premises on which the analysis of economic problems proceeds, the range of problems usually taken up for investigation by economists, the methods of procedure adopted in their solution, the character of the solutions sought or arrived at, the relations of Political Economy to the other Moral Sciences, as well as to the influence of the political, social, and industrial situation in determining the scope and aim of economic investigation. Special attention is given to writers on method, as Mill, Cairnes, Keynes, Roscher, Schmoller, Menger.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 11:00.
Assistant Professor Veblen.

  1. Finance. — In this course it is intended to make a comprehensive survey of the whole field of public finance. The treatment is both theoretical and practical, and the method of presentation historical as well as systematic. Most emphasis is placed upon the study of taxation, although public expenditures, public debts, and financial administration are carefully studied.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 8:30.
Assistant Professor Davenport.

  1. Tariffs, Reciprocity, and Shipping. — The course of legislation and the development of our commercial policy is followed, and an effort made to indicate the influence of our protective tariffs upon the development of our domestic industries, upon the growth and character of our international trade, and incidentally upon the occurrence of industrial crises and the continuance of industrial prosperity at different periods in our history. Foreign trade policies and schemes for imperial tariff federation are taken up, and especial attention given to the negotiation of reciprocity treaties, as well as to recent attempts which have been made through federal legislation granting subsidies to build up American shipping.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 11:00.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

  1. Financial History of the United States. — In this course the financial history of the United States is followed from the organization of our national system in 1789 to the close of the Spanish war. The following topics may be mentioned as indicating the scope of the course; the funding and management of the Revolutionary and other war debts; the First and Second United States Banks; the Independent Treasury; the present national banking system; Civil War financiering with especial reference to bond and note issues, and resort to legal tender currency; the demonetization of silver and issue of silver certificates; inflation of the currency and the gold reserve; the currency act of 1900. This study of the course of legislation upon currency, debts, and banking in the United States is based upon first-hand examination of sources, and students are expected to do original research work.

Summer Quarter; 8:00.
Mj. Autumn Quarter; 9:30.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

  1. Economic Factors in Civilization. — The course is intended to present a genetic account of the modern economic system by a study of its beginnings and the phases of development through which the present situation has been reached. To this end it undertakes a survey of the growth of culture as affected by economic motives and conditions. With this in view, such phenomena as the Teutonic invasion of Europe, the Feudal system, the rise of commerce, the organization of trade and industry, the history of the condition of laborers, processes of production, and changes in consumption, will be treated.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 11:00.
Assistant Professor Veblen.

  1. Problems of American Agriculture. — Special attention will be given to the extension and changes of the cultivated area of the United States; the methods of farming; the influence of railways and population, and of cheapened transportation; the fall in value of Eastern farm lands; movements of prices of agricultural products; European markets; competition of other countries; intensive farming; diminishing returns; farm mortgages; and the comparison of American with European systems of culture.

Summer Quarter; 10:30.
Mj. Winter Quarter; 9:30.
Assistant Professor Hill.

  1. Colonial Economics. — The economics of colonial administration, including some account of commercialism, past and present, and of modern trade theories of imperial federation, trade relations, financial policies, and economic development and dependence of colonies.
    A brief historical account of American and foreign experience serves as introduction to a fuller consideration of economic problems involved in modern colonial administration. In the light of this experience study is undertaken of some economic problems which have arisen in Cuba, Porto Rico, Hawaii, and the Philippine Islands.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 9:30.
Mr. Morris.

29, 30. Oral Debates. — Selected Economic Topics. Briefs. Debates. Criticism.

2M. Autumn and Winter Quarters; Mon., 3:00-6:00.
Assistant Professor Hill, Mr. Chandler, and Mr. Gorsuch.

31, 32. Argumentation. — To be taken in connection with English 9.

2 hrs. a week.
2M. Autumn and Winter Quarters; Wed., 3:00.
2M. Autumn and Winter Quarters.
Mr. Chandler.

Group IV. — Labor and Capital.
  1. Theory of Value. — After a brief preliminary survey of the discussions prior to Adam Smith, the cost of production-theory as developed at the hands of Ricardo, McCulloch, James Mill, Senior, J. S. Mill, and Cairnes is taken up for detailed study. Then the utility theory of value, as presented by Jevons and Austrian economists, is examined. Finally, the attempts made by such writers as Marshall, Dietzel, Pantaleoni, Clark, Patten, McFarlane, Hobson, etc., to frame a more satisfactory theory of value by combining the analysis of cost and of marginal utility, are reviewed.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 8: 30.
Assistant Professor Davenport.

  1. Labor and Capital. — Unsettled problems of distribution. The more abstruse questions of distribution will be considered. No student, therefore, can undertake the work of this course with profit who has not already become familiar with the fundamental principles. The course is open only to those who have passed satisfactorily Course 2, or who can clearly show that they have had an equivalent training. The subjects to be considered will be as follows: The wages-fund and other theories of wages, the interest problem, managers’ profits, and allied topics. The discussion will be based upon selected passages of important writers. The study of wages, for example, will include reading from Adam Smith, Ricardo, J. S. Mill, Longe, Thornton, Cairnes, F. A. Walker, Marshall, George, Böhm-Bawerk, Hobson, J. B. Clark, and others. Students will also be expected to discuss recent important contributions to these subjects in current books or journals.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 12:00.
Professor Laughlin.

  1. Economics of Workingmen. — Continuing the study of distribution (Course 41), examination is here undertaken of social movements for improving the condition of labor, to determine how far they are consistent with economic teaching, and likely in fact to facilitate or to retard economic betterment of workingmen. Efforts to increase earnings through modification of the wages system itself, resort to legislation, and the purposes and practices of labor organization are discussed, and the effect upon labor efficiency, earning capacity and steadiness of employment, of modern industrial systems; workingmen’s insurance; co-operation; profit-sharing; competition of women and children; industrial education; social-settlement work; consumers’ leagues. Interest centers about practical efforts for economic amelioration of employment conditions in “sweated” and in other industries. These studies are supplemented by statistical data on the condition of labor in different countries.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 9:30.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

Note. — Although open in certain cases to students of Sociology and others who have had the equivalent of the economic Courses 1 and 2, this course can be taken to best advantage by those only who have already had Course 41.

  1. Socialism — A history of the growth of socialistic sentiment and opinion as shown in the socialistic movements of the nineteenth century, and the position occupied by socialistic organizations of the present time. The course is in part historical and descriptive, in part theoretical and critical. The programmes and platforms of various socialistic organizations are examined and compared, and the theories of leading socialists are taken up in detail. Marx is given the chief share of attention, but other theoretical writers, such as Rodbertus, Kautsky, Bernstein, are also reviewed. The factors which at the present time further or hinder the spread of socialism, and what are its chances of being carried through or of producing a serious effect upon the institutions of modern countries, are considered.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 9:30.
Assistant Professor Veblen.

  1. Organization of Business Enterprise—Trusts. — A discussion of the growth of the conditions which have made large business coalitions possible, the motives which have led to their formation, the conditions requisite to their successful operation, the character and extent of the advantages to be derived from them, the drawbacks and dangers which may be involved in their further growth, the chances of governmental guidance or limitation of their formation and of the exercise of their power, the feasible policy and methods that may be pursued in dealing with the trusts. The work of the course is in large part investigation of special subjects, with lectures and assigned reading.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 9:30.
Assistant Professor Veblen.

  1. Trades Unions and the Labor Movement — An historical and comparative study of the trades union movement in the United States and in foreign countries. Negotiation and maintenance of wage-compacts; methods of arbitration, conciliation and adjustment; trades union insurance and provision for the unemployed; incorporation and employés’ liability; the precipitation and conduct of strikes; and in general all concrete issues involved in the organization of labor for collective bargaining with employers, with especial reference to the working programs of the more important trades unions at the present time.

Summer Quarter; 9:00.
Mj. Spring Quarter; 12:00.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

  1. The Industrial Revolution and Labor Legislation. — The social consequences to the wage-earner of the development of the factory system of industry and of industrial development, more particularly during the last half of the 19th century, are taken up historically and descriptively. The social status of the modern wage-earner is contrasted with that of the handicraftsman working under more primitive conditions, and especial attention is given to the development of the modern wages system of remuneration, the historical modification of the labor contract in its legal aspects, and, finally, to the course of labor legislation which has in different countries accompanied industrial reorganization and development.

Mj.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

[Not to be given in 1904-5.]

Group V — Money and Banking.
  1. Money and Practical Economics.— An examination is first made of the principles of money, whether metallic or paper; then either the subject of metallic or paper money is taken up and studied historically, chiefly in connection with the experience of the United States, as a means of putting the principles into practice. Preliminary training for investigation is combined in this course, with the acquisition of desirable statistical information on practical questions of the day. The student is instructed in the bibliography of the subject, taught how to collect his data, and expected to weigh carefully the evidence on both sides of a mooted question. The work of writing theses is so adjusted that it corresponds to the work of other courses counting for the same number of hours.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 12:00.
Professor Laughlin.

  1. The Theory and History of Banking. — A study is made of the banking systems of leading nations; the relations of the banks to the public; their influence on speculation; and the relative advantages of national banks, state banks, trust companies, and savings banks.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 8:30.
Mr. ———.

  1. Advanced Course in Money. — After having been drilled in the general principles of money (Course 50) the student is given an opportunity to examine the more difficult problems of money and credit.

Mj. Spring Quarter.
Professor Laughlin.

[Not given in 1904-5.1

  1. Practical Banking. — The internal organization and administration of a bank; the granting of loans; the valuation of an account; bank records; arithmetic of bank operations; mechanical and other time-saving devices.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 8:30.
Mr. ———.

  1. Commercial Crises. — A practical study of the operations of credit in the experiences of this and other countries during the periods of crises.

Mj. Spring Quarter.
Mr. ———.

[Not given in 1901-5.]

Group VI — Railways.
  1. Railway Transportation. — The economic, financial, and social influences arising from the growth of modern railway transportation, especially as concerns the United States, will be discussed. An account of the means of transportation developed in Europe and America during the early part of this century; the experiments of the states in constructing and operating canals and railways; national, state, and municipal aid to private companies; the rapid and irregular extension of the United States railway system; the failures of 1893; the reorganizations and consolidations since that time, with some attention to railway building in other countries, will form the historical part of the work. A discussion of competition, combination, discrimination, investments, speculation, abuse of fiduciary powers; state legislation and commissions, and the Inter-State Commerce Act, with decisions under it; and the various relations of the state, the public, the investors, the managers and the employés, will form the most important part of the work. This course gives a general view of the subject. Students who wish to continue the work by investigating special problems will have an opportunity to do so under Courses 61 and 62.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 2:00
Assistant Professor Hill.

  1. The Regulation of Railway Rates. — The efforts of the railways of the United States to regulate railway rates through pools, will be compared with the efforts of the several states, and of the federal government, to regulate rates through legislation and through commissions. Typical decisions of pools, of state commissions, and of the Interstate Commerce Commission, will be studied for the purpose of ascertaining: (a) whether the decisions of the commissions are founded on a body of principles that may be said to have the character of a science, or, whether they express merely the judgment of administrative officers on questions of fact to which no body of scientific principles can be made to apply; (b) whether the past experience warrants the faith that the public regulation of railway rates will leave the railways sufficiently unhampered to develop trade and industry; (c) whether regulation by public authority promises to achieve more substantial justice than regulation by pools. The experience of Germany, France, Austria-Hungary, and Russia with the public regulation of railway rates — exercised either by legislation or by public ownership — will be studied with reference to the effect of such regulation upon the elasticity of railway rates, and upon the ability of the railways to develop trade and industry. In this connection will be studied the part played respectively by the railways and by the waterways in the development of Germany, France, Austria-Hungary, and Russia. The study will show why the countries in question are obliged to have recourse to the waterways for services that, in the United States, are rendered by the railways.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 2:00.
Assistant Professor Meyer.

  1. Industrial Activities of the State in Europe. — This course reviews the efforts made in Great Britain to secure to the public a share in the profits to be made in those so-called public service industries that use the streets: water, gas, electric light, street-railways, and hydraulic power, or compressed air, power transmission. These efforts consist of the imposition of severe restrictions upon franchises, with the alternative of municipal ownership. The experience of Great Britain will be compared with that of the United States, under: (a) the practice of practically no restrictions upon the industries in question; (b) the Massachusetts practice of regulation by legislation which is enforced and supplemented by state commissions. As for Continental Europe, the course will cover the experience of Prussia, France, and Russia, in attempting to make the railway and public works budgets fit into the state budget. In this connection the inelasticity of state activity in Europe will be compared with the elasticity of private activity in the United States.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 3:00.
Assistant Professor Meyer.

  1. The Industrial Activities of the State in Australasia. — This course will cover the Australasian experience of the last forty years under a wide extension of the functions of the state. Although Australasia is a comparatively small country, the experience in question is more significant than might appear at first sight, for it is the experience of a homogeneous, English-speaking people. The course will cover the management of the state-railways; the administration of the public finances; the civil service; and the legislative regulation of the conditions of labor, such as the fixing of minimum wages, and the establishment of compulsory arbitration. Incidentally comparisons will be made with certain conditions and practices in Great Britain and France, for the purpose of showing how the extension of the functions of the state has made the politics of Australasia resemble, in many vital respects, the politics of France, rather than those of Great Britain.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 2:00.
Assistant Professor Meyer.

  1. American Competition in Europe since 1873. — This course is a study in economics and politics; it purposes to put before the student information equipping him for the critical consideration of the merits of the question: Laissez faire vs. state intervention. To that end it institutes a series of comparisons between the United States and Europe, especially in the fields of agricultural practice and railway transportation. The course begins with the consideration of the nature of the competition to which the opening of new sources of supply of food products exposed Western Europe, the nature of the adjustments demanded by the situation, and the adjustments actually achieved, under free-trade in Great Britain, and under protection on the Continent. The course then proceeds to contrast the comparative failure to develop the agricultural resources of Eastern Europe (the Danubian Provinces and Russia) and Siberia with the rapid development of the agricultural resources of the interior regions of the United States. In this connection will be studied the comparative efficiency of the railway systems of Europe and the United States, with especial reference to the effect of the public regulation of railway rates, either through state-ownership, or through legislative and administrative intervention. Incidental to the main investigation an array of facts will be presented bearing upon questions of economic theory: the growth of population and the raising of the standard of living; some of the principal factors that have determined the present scale of real wages in the several European countries; some instances of the working of natural selection; and the relative merits of large farms and small farms, or of extensive cultivation and intensive cultivation.

Mj. Spring Quarter; 3:00.
Assistant Professor Meyer.

Group VII — Statistics.
  1. Training Course in Statistics. — The object of this course is to train students in the practical use of statistical methods of investigation. Stress is laid upon work done by students themselves in collecting, tabulating, interpreting, and presenting statistics of different orders. Members of the class are also required to make close critical examinations of various publications of statistical nature with a view to determining the accuracy of data and the legitimacy of inferences drawn. Students engaged in any special work of investigation are encouraged to deal mainly with data relevant to their subjects. To others special topics are assigned. It is hoped that the course may prove useful to all students whose work, in whatever department it may lie, whether in history, sociology, or in other fields of study, is susceptible of statistical treatment.
    Courses 70 and 72 will be given in alternate years.

Mj. Autumn Quarter; 8:30.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

  1. Statistics of Wages in the Nineteenth Century. — In this course effort is made to determine what has been the actual movement of wages during the nineteenth century. An examination is undertaken of the more important statistical investigations of wage movements which have been made from time to time by economists, government bureaus, or other agencies, in specific industries; the object being to determine the extent to which the wage-earner has in general participated in the benefits of industrial progress and of the increased economic efficiency of labor and capital. The course is intended to be informational and descriptive in character, as well as to give training in the collection and tabulation of statistical data.

Mj. Winter Quarter; 12:00.
Assistant Professor Cummings.

  1. Demography. — Statistical methods are illustrated by studies in population data, comprising the construction of actuarial tables; determination of the economic value of populations; economic aspects of the data of criminality and pauperism; growth and migration of population in the United States as “labor force,” including statistics of the negro race. The development of official statistics of population, and the demographic work of government bureaus is taken up historically and critically. The object of the course is to give students training in handling population data as a basis of sociological and economic speculation, and to point out the bearing of such data and their importance in the historical development of economic theories.

Assistant Professor Cummings.

[Not to be given in 1904-5.]

Group VIII — The Seminars.

80, 81. Economic Seminar.

2Mj. Autumn and Winter Quarters.
Professor Laughlin.

Source: University of Chicago. Programme of the Departments of Political Economy, Political Science, History, Sociology and Anthropology, 1904-1905. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1904. Transcription from a copy found in the Harvard University Archives, Division of History, Government, and Economics. Ph.D. exams and records of candidates, study plans, lists, etc. pre-1911-1942. Box 2, Unlabeled Folder.

Image Source: Technology Reading Room 2, Crerar Library (Marshall Field Annex). From the University of Chicago Photographic Archive, apf2-01949, Hanna Holborn Gray Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library.

Categories
Economists Harvard Transcript

Harvard. Application for PhD candidacy. James Waterhouse Angell, 1921

The empirical questions behind most of the collection of archival artifacts found here at Economics in the Rear-view Mirror can be reduced to i) what was being taught ii) who was teaching it, and iii) what was the pattern of the courses actually taken by young economists. These artifacts can be thought of as occupying cell(s) in a matrix of year by academic institution, e.g. this post deals with question (iii) and will be filed in the Harvard, early 1920’s cell.

James Waterhouse Angell (1898-1986) was a Harvard and Chicago trained economist who joined the Columbia faculty upon receiving his Ph.D. from Harvard in 1924. He was a member of Columbia’s faculty for over forty years, interrupted by government service during World War II at the War Production Board and the Foreign Economics Administration.  More about his life and career can be read in his New York Times obituary (April 1, 1986)

With this post we have the record for Angell in Harvard’s Division of History, Government, and Economics. It provides us with a wealth of information about his academic training. There will be a flow of such records for other graduate students that promises to match the flow of syllabi and exams, the stock of which constitute the core of archival material.

 You  should subscribe to Economics in the Rear-view Mirror if you are working on the history of economics. To do so scroll down (or search “Subscribe” on this page from your web browser).

_______________________

Autobiographical snippet

Angell’s personal statement in the 25th year anniversary report of the Harvard Class of 1918

_______________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
DIVISION OF HISTORY, GOVERNMENT, AND ECONOMICS

Application for Candidacy for the Degree of Ph.D.

[Note: Boldface used to indicate printed text of the application; italics used to indicate the handwritten entries]

I. Full Name, with date and place of birth.

James Waterhouse Angell. May 20, 1898. Chicago.

II. Academic Career: (Mention, with dates inclusive, colleges or other higher institutions of learning attended; and teaching positions held.)

Undergraduate: Harvard 1914-18. Graduate: University of Chicago, March 1919-June 1920; Harvard, September 1920-date. Teaching: Assistant in Economics, Univ. of Chicago, October 1919-June 1920.

III. Degrees already attained. (Mention institutions and dates.)

A.B. Harvard, 1918. [magna cum laude]

IV. General Preparation. (Indicate briefly the range and character of your undergraduate studies in History, Economics, Government, and in such other fields as Ancient and Modern Languages, Philosophy, etc.) In case you are a candidate for the degree in History, state the number of years you have studied preparatory and college Latin.)

History. Harvard: Hist. A, 30a. Government. Univ. of Chicago: Elementary Comp. Govt. Economics. Harvard: Economics A, 2a, 2b, 4b, 5a, 5b. Univ. of Chicago: Labor Problems, Money and Banking, Statistics.

Greek: Harvard: Greek G, A, 2, 8. Latin. Harvard: Latin B, 8. French. Harvard: French 2. Philosophy. Univ. of Chicago: Social and Political Philosophy. Psychology. Harvard: Psychology A, Univ. of Chicago: Social Psychology.

V. Department of Study. (Do you propose to offer yourself for the Ph.D., “History,” in “Economics,” or in “Political Science”?)

Economics

VI. Choice of Subjects for the General Examination. (State briefly the nature of your preparation in each subject, as by Harvard courses, courses taken elsewhere, private reading, teaching the subject, etc., etc.)

  1. Economic Theory and Its History. Harvard: Economics A, 11, 14; Univ. of Chicago: History of Econ. Thought. Teaching: Univ. of Chicago: 2 quarters of elementary theory, 1920.
  2. Economic History since 1750. Harvard: Economics 2a and 2b.
  3. Public FinanceHarvard: Economics 5a, 5b, 31
  4. Money and Banking. Harvard: Economics 38. Univ. of Chicago: Elementary Money & Banking. Also private reading.
  5. International Trade and Tariff Policy. Harvard: Economics 33; and private reading.
  6. [Constitutional] History of the U.S., 1789-1914Univ. of Chicago. 3 quarters of graduate study. (A. D. Mr. Laughlin)

VII. Special Subject for the special examination.

Special subject either Economic Theory or Public Finance; to be specified later. Money and Banking

VIII. Thesis Subject. (State the subject and mention the instructor who knows most about your work upon it.)

International Price Levels (With Professors Taussig and Young)

IX. Examinations. (Indicate any preferences as to the time of the general and special examinations.)

General: Last week in October, 1921.

X. Remarks

[Left blank]

Signature of a member of the Division certifying approval of the above outline of subjects.

[signed] Edmund E. Day

*   *   *   [Last page of application] *   *   *

[Not to be filled out by the applicant]

Name: James W. Angell

Approved: April 29, 1921

Ability to use French certified by Charles J. Bullock. 10 March, 1922 B.S.M.

Ability to use German certified by Charles J. Bullock, 10 March, 1922 B.S.M.

Date of general examination June 2, 1922 Passed A.A.Y.

Thesis received Oct. 15, 1923

Read by Professors Taussig, Young, and Persons

Approved October 29, 1921

Date of special examination Thursday, March 6, 1924. Passed A.A. Young 

Recommended for the Doctorate[left blank]

Degree conferred  [left blank]

Remarks.  [left blank]

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

Record of James Waterhouse Angell in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Harvard University

1920-21
Economics 11.
[Economic Theory, Prof. Taussig]
A
Economics 14
[History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848, Prof. Bullock]
A minus
Economics 31
[Public Finance, Prof. Bullock]
A
Economics 331 [half course]
[International Trade and Tariff Problems, Prof. Taussig]
A
Economics 382 [half course]
[Selected Monetary Problems, Prof. Young]
A
Attained the degree of Master of Arts.
1921-22
Economics 20 (F.W.T.)
[Economic Research (for Ph.D. candidates)]
A

Note: A transcript can also be found in Harvard University Archives, Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. Record Cards of Students, 1895-1930, Aab—Belcher (UAV 161.2722.5). File I, Box 1, Record Card of James Waterhouse Angell.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Committee on Economic Research
Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S.A.
Charles J. Bullock, Chairman

Charles F. Adams
Nicholas Biddle
Frederic H. Curtiss
Wallace B. Donham
Ogden L. Mills
Eugene V. R. Thayer

W.M. Persons, Editor
Review of Economic Statistics

J.B. Hubbard, Editor
Harvard Economic Service

F.Y. Presley
General Manager

March 10, 1922.

Professor Charles H. Haskins,
23 University Hall,
Cambridge, Mass.

This is to certify that I have examined Mr. J. W. Angell and find that he has such a knowledge of French and German as we require of candidates for the doctor’s degree.

[signed] Charles J. Bullock

CJB/AMB

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
DIVISION OF HISTORY, GOVERNMENT, AND ECONOMICS

Cambridge, Massachusetts
6 June 1922

I beg to report that Mr. James W. Angell passed the General Examination in Economics held on Friday, 2 June. Mr. Angell’s examination clearly earned a pass, but it is proper to say that the examination was not as distinguished and the margin was not as large as Mr. Angell’s brilliant course record indicated it would be.

[signed by D.C. for] Allyn A. Young

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

[Carbon copy]

26 February 1924

My dear Professor Young:

We are arranging J.W. Angell’s special examination for Thursday, 6 March, at 4 p.m. I will let you know the place later. The committee will consist of Professors Taussig, Williams, Sprague, and yourself as chairman.

Very truly yours,
Secretary of the Division.

Professor A. A. Young

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
DIVISION OF HISTORY, GOVERNMENT, AND ECONOMICS

Cambridge, Massachusetts
March 7, 1924

Dear Haskins:

On behalf of the committee appointed to conduct the special examination of Mr. J. W. Angell, I beg to report that Mr. Angell successfully passed the examination. I may add that the examination as a whole was unusually satisfactory.

Very truly yours,
[signed by k. for] Allyn A. Young

Dean C. H. Haskins

Source: Harvard University Archives. Division of History, Government, and Economics. Ph.D. exams and records of candidates, study plans, lists, etc. pre-1911-1942. Box 5. Folder “J. W. Angell.”

_______________________

Annotated Typescript for
Division of History, Government, and Economics
Examinations for the Degree of Ph.D. 1923-1924
JAMES WATERHOUSE ANGELL.

SPECIAL EXAMINATION in Economics, passed. Thursday, March 6, 1924.

GENERAL EXAMINATION passed June 2, 1922.

ACADEMIC HISTORY: Harvard College, 1914-18; University of Chicago, March, 1919, to June, 1920; Harvard Graduate School, 1920-23. A.B., 1918; A.M., 1921. Assistant in Economics, University of Chicago, 1919-20; Tutor in the Division of History, Government, and Economics, Harvard, 1921-22; Frederick Sheldon Travelling Fellow, Harvard, 1922-23; Instructor in Economics and Tutor in the Division of History, Government, and Economics, Harvard, 1923-4.

GENERAL SUBJECTS: 1. Economic Theory and Its History. 2. Economic History since 1750. 3. Public Finance. 4. Money and Banking. 5. International Trade and Tariff Policy. 6. American History since 1789.

SPECIAL SUBJECT: Money and Banking.

COMMITTEE: Professors Young (chairman), Taussig, Williams,
and Sprague.

THESIS SUBJECT: The Theory of International Prices and its History.

COMMITTEE ON THESIS: Professors Taussig, Young, and Persons.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Division of History, Government, and Economics. Ph.D. exams and records of candidates, study plans, lists, etc. pre-1911-1942. Box 5. Unmarked Envelope/Folder

_______________________

Image Source:  James Waterhouse Angell’s July 18, 1922 U.S. passport application. National Archives.

 

Categories
Economic History Exam Questions Harvard Suggested Reading Syllabus

Harvard. Reading list and final exam for U.S. economic and financial history. Taussig and Gay, 1905-1906

Assistant Professor Oliver Mitchell Wentworth Sprague taught the Harvard course “Economic History of the United States”/ “Economic and Financial History of the United States” in 1901-02 (with James Horace Patten), 1902-03, 1903-04, and 1904-05. The course was taken over in 1905-06 by Frank William Taussig and Edwin Francis Gay after Sprague left for a full professorship at the Imperial University of Japan.

__________________________

Course Enrollment
1905-06

Economics 6 2hf. Professor Taussig and Asst. Professor Gay. — Economic and Financial History of the United States.

Total 79: 14 Graduates, 15 Seniors, 37 Juniors, 10 Sophomores, 3 Others.

Source: Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1905-1906, p. 72.

__________________________

READING FOR ECONOMICS 6
(1905-6)

Prescribed reading is indicated by an asterisk (*).

1. COLONIAL PERIOD.

*Ashley, Commercial Legislation of England and the American Colonies, Q.J.E., Vol. XIV, pp. 1-30; printed also in Surveys, pp. 309-335.

Schmoller, Mercantile System, pp. 57-80.

Beer, Commercial Policy of England, pp. 1-158.

Rabbeno, American Commercial Policy, pp. 3-91.

Eggleston, Agriculture and Commerce in the Colonies, The Century Magazine, Jan. and June, 1884, Vol. V, pp. 431-449; Vol. VI, pp. 234-256.

2. COMMERCE AND MANUFACTURES, 1776-1815.

*Hill, First Stages of the Tariff Policy of the United States, Amer Econ. Assn. Pub., Vol. VIII, pp. 107-132.

Pitkin, Statistical View of the United States, ed. 1835, ch. ix, pp. 368-412.

Rabbeno, American Commercial Policy, pp. 287-324, 95-145.

Hamilton, Report on Manufactures, in Taussig’s State Papers and Speeches on the Tariff, pp. 1-108.

3. REVOLUTIONARY AND NATIONAL FINANCE – WESTWARD MOVEMENT, 1776-1815.

*Dewey, Financial History of the United States, chs. ii-vi, pp. 33-141.

Bullock, Essays on the Monetary History of the United States, pp. 60-78.

Hamilton, Reports on Public Credit, Amer. State Papers, Finance, Vol. 1, pp. 15-37, 64-67.

Turner, Significance of the Frontier in American History, in Report of Amer. Hist. Assn., 1893, pp. 199-227.

Semple, American History and its Geographical Conditions, chs. iv, v, pp. 52-92.

4. FINANCE AND BANKING, 1815-1860.

*Dewey, Financial History, pp. 223-237, 252-262.

Sumner, Andrew Jackson, ed. 1886, pp. 224-249, 257-276, 291-342.

Catterall, The Second Bank of the United States, chs. xvi-vviii, pp. 376-403, 430-452.

Conant, History of Modern Banks of Issue, ch. xiv, pp. 310-347.

White, Money and Banking, chs. ix-xii, pp. 324-361.

5. TARIFFS AND MANUFACTURES, 1815-1860.

*Taussig, Tariff History, pp. 1-154.

Taussig, State Papers and Speeches on the Tariff, pp. 108-385.

Rabbeno, American Commercial Policy, 146-199, 325-383.

6. INTERNAL IMPROVEMENTS, 1815-1860.

*Callender, Early Transportation and Banking Enterprises, Q.J.E., Vol. XVII, pp. 111-162.

Chevalier, Society, Manners, and Politics in the United States, chs. vii, xx, xxi, pp. 80-87, 209-276.

Pitkin, Statistical View (1835), Vol. XII, pp. 531-581.

Gallatin, Plan of Internal Improvements, Amer. State Papers, Misc., Vol. I.

Tanner, Railways and Canals of the United States. See, especially, the map.

7. LAND POLICY AND AGRICULTURE, 1815-1860.

*Hart, Practical Essays on American Government, pp. 233-257.

*Hammond, Cotton Industry, ch. iii, pp. 67-119.

Donaldson, Public Domain.

Sato, History of the Land Question in the United States, Johns Hopkins University Studies, 4th series, nos. 7-9, pp. 127-181.

8. POPULATION AND SLAVERY, 1815-1860.

*Cairnes, Slave Power, chs. ii, iii, v, pp. 34-93, 120-150.

Hammond, Cotton Industry, ch. ii, pp. 34-60.

Semple, American History and its Geographic Conditions, ch. ix, pp. 150-177.

9. FINANCE, BANKING, AND CURRENCY PROBLEMS, 1860-1900.

*Dewey, Financial History, chs. xii, xiii, xx, pp. 271-330, 463-473.

*Noyes, Thirty Years of American Finance, chs. i, ii, iii, x, pp. 1-72, 234-254.

Taussig, Silver Situation, pp. 1-157.

Dunbar, National Banking System, Q.J.E., Vol. XII, pp. 1-36.

10. TRANSPORTATION; TARIFF.

*Taussig, Tariff History, pp. 155-230.

Industrial Commission, Vol. XIX, pp. 466-481.

Johnson, American Railway Transportation, chs. ii, ii, v, pp. 13-38, 52-68.

Taussig, Contribution to the Theory of Railway Rates, Q.J.E., Vol. V, pp. 438-465.

Hadley, Railroad Transportation, pp. 24-56.

11. INDUSTRIAL EXPANSION AND TARIFF.

*Taussig, Tariff History, pp. 230-409.

Stanwood, American Tariff Controversies, Vol. II, pp. 243-394.

Taussig, Iron Industry, Q.J.E., Vol. XIV, pp. 143-170, 475-508.

Industrial Commission, Vol. XIX, pp. 485-519, 544-569.

Twelfth United States Census, Vol. IX, pp. 1-16; Vol. X, pp. 723-743.

Taussig, Wool and Woolens, Q.J.E., Vol. VIII, pp. 1-39.

Wright, Wool-growing and the Tariff since 1890, Q.J.E., Vol. XIX, pp. 610-647.

Willoughby, Integration of Industry in the United States, Q.J.E., Vol. XVI, pp. 94-115.

12. AGRICULTURE AND OPENING OF THE FAR WEST.

*Industrial Commission, XIX, pp. 43-123, 134-168.

Hammond, Cotton Industry, Book I, chs. iv-vii, ix, pp. 120-228, 324-356.

Adams, The Granger Movement, North American Review, Vol. CLXXV, pp. 394-424.

13. COMMERCE AND SHIPPING.

*Meeker, Shipping Subsidies, Pol. Sci. Qr., Vol. XX, pp. 594-611.

*Noyes, Recent Economic History of the United States, Q.J.E., Vol. XIX, pp. 167-209.

Wells, Our Merchant Marine, chs. i-v, pp. 1-94.

14. WAGES AND THE LABOR PROBLEM.

*Levasseur, American Workman, pp. 436-509.

Mitchell, Organized Labor.

Industrial Conciliation, National Civic Federation.

Wright, Industrial History of the United States, Part III, pp. 231-322.

15. IMMIGRATION AND THE RACE QUESTION.

*Mayo-Smith, Emigration and Immigration, chs. iii, iv, pp. 33-78.

Tillinghast, Negro in Africa and America, pp. 102-227.

Hoffman, Race Traits and Tendencies of the American Negro, pp. 141-148, 170-176, 310-329.

Washington, Future of the American Negro, pp. 3-244.

Mayo-Smith, Emigration and Immigration, pp. 79-167, 227-283.

Walker, Discussions in Economics and Statistics, Vol. II, pp. 417-434.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in conomics, 1895-2003, Box 1, Folder “Economics, 1905-1906”.

__________________________

ECONOMICS 6
Year-end Examination, 1905-06

  1. Describe the history of the agitation for “cheap money” in the United States; the forms assumed both before and after 1860, its causes and the probability of its recurrence.
  2. Compare critically the financing of the Revolutionary War, the Civil War, and the Spanish War.
  3. (a) Summarize the principal features of our tariff legislation from the close of the Civil War to the Dingley Tariff.
    (b) What has been the effect of the tariffs on the iron and steel industry?
  4. Give the history of the Union Pacific Railroad and its relations to the government.
  5. Account for the changes in the character of the foreign trade of the United States in respect to the excess of imports or of exports.
    Take one of the following questions:
  6. Discuss the significance and causes of the increase of farm tenancy and the rural exodus.
  7. What can you say as to agricultural conditions in the South before and since the Civil War? What about the negro problem?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University, Examination Papers 1873-1915. Box 8, Bound volume: Examination Papers, 1906-07; Papers Set for Final Examinations in History, Government, Economics,…,Music in Harvard College (June, 1906), pp. 31-32.

Image Source: Portraits of Frank William Taussig and Edwin Francis Gay from the Harvard Class Album 1906.

 

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Transportation

Harvard. Final examination for transportation economics. Ripley, 1905-1906

Relatively early on transportation economics was recognised as one of the major specialisation fields within applied economics. This can be illustrated with the courses offered by William Zebina Ripley at Harvard that were introduced during the first decade of the twentieth century. Ripley also covered labor relations as well as industrial organisation and regulation. This was still a time when economics faculty members were expected to span several special fields. As Adam Smith had said, “The division of labour is limited by the extent of the market.” The era of the “Universalgenie” [Narrator’s voice: “They only thought they were.”] had not yet been replaced by the era of the “Fachidiot” [The narrator continues, “…ahem, present company excluded”].

__________________________

Earlier exams etc. for Economics 5

1900-01 (Hugo Richard Meyer alone)
1901-02 (Ripley with Hugo Richard Meyer)
1903-04 (Ripley alone)
1904-05 (Ripley with Stuart Daggett)

__________________________

Course Enrollment
1905-06

Economics 5 1hf. Professor [William Zebina] Ripley, assisted by Mr. [Stuart] Daggett. — Economics of Transportation.

Total 138: 10 Graduates, 32 Seniors, 59 Juniors, 28 Sophomores, 9 Others.

Source: Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1905-1906, p. 72.

__________________________

ECONOMICS 5
Final Examination
1905-06

  1. What is the present legal status of the “Long and Short Haul” clause of the Act to Regulate Commerce? Outline the decisions clearly.
  2. The average length of haul on the St. Paul road is about 185 miles; while on the Union Pacific it is about 386 miles. How would these conditions affect the revenue per ton mile?
  3. What advantages might follow the repeal of the prohibition of pooling, from a railway point of view?
  4. What authority has the Interstate Commerce Commission concerning witnesses and the production of papers? What is the latest decision?
  5. Should the following items of expenditure be charged to capital, improvement, or operating expense account, viz.: (1) cost of abolishing grade crossings; (2) replacement of light rails with heavy ones; and (3) premium on purchase of stock in a subsidiary road? Give your own reasons for whichever course you advocate.
  6. What is the present method of control of the anthracite coal roads?
  7. What are the main inducements for stock watering, as described by Johnson?
  8. What is the nature of the principal bills now before Congress, amending the Act to Regulate Commerce? Describe them separately.

Source:  Harvard University, Examination Papers 1873-1915. Box 7, Bound volume: Examination Papers, 1905-06;  Papers Set for Final Examinations in History, Government, Economics,…,Music in Harvard College(June, 1906), p. 31.

Image Source: Harvard University Archives.  William Zebina Ripley [photographic portrait, ca. 1910], J. E. Purdy & Co., J. E. P. & C. (1910). Colorized by Economics in the Rear-view Mirror.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Sociology

Harvard. Final exam questions for principles of sociology. Carver, 1905-1906

 

Excerpts from Thomas Nixon Carvers’s autobiography dealing with sociology, his course reading list and a “thick” course description from the 1904-05 academic year have been transcribed and posted earlier.

Image today having a question like “What are the chief factors tending to promote the improvement of the race, and what are the chief factors tending to deteriorate it?” standing between you and your final grade in a course.

I wonder when such a question was first able to elicit a consensus cringe among social scientists. 

Likely readings for this course can be found in Sociology and Social Progress, compiled by Thomas Nixon Carver (Boston: Ginn and Company, 1905).

__________________________

Course Enrollment

Economics 3. Professor Carver. — Principles of Sociology. Theories of Social Progress.

Total 60: 9 Graduates, 11 Seniors, 23 Juniors, 13 Sophomores, 4 Others.

Source: Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1905-1906, p. 72.

__________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
ECONOMICS 3
Mid-year Examination, 1905-06

  1. State and explain briefly, —
    1. Spencer’s position as to the possibility of a science of society.
    2. Bagehot’s conclusion as to verifiable progress.
    3. Kidd’s theory as to the function of religious beliefs in the development of society.
    4. Kidd’s prediction as to the future relation of European races to tropical regions.
  2. What are the chief factors tending to promote the improvement of the race, and what are the chief factors tending to deteriorate it?
  3. Discuss briefly the following topics in their relation to social development:
    1. “The consciousness of kind.”
    2. Imitation
    3. Resentment.
    4. The power of idealization.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University. Mid-year Examinations, 1852-1943. Box 7, Bound Volume: Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1905-06.

__________________________

ECONOMICS 3
Year-end Examination, 1905-06

  1. Discuss Kidd’s view that the real drift of society is toward greater equality and that this is accompanied by keener competition.
  2. Can social progress be defined in terms of human well being? Explain.
  3. What is meant by the transition from a pain to a pleasure economy? What corresponding transition does Comte describe?
  4. If we grant that war is primarily due to economic reasons, does the conclusion follow that it is permanent?
  5. What importance attaches to the prolongation of infancy in the human species?
  6. Compare the views of Kidd and Buckle as to the relative importance of the moral and the intellectual factors in social development.
  7. What is meant by the storing of social energy, and what are some of the chief agencies by which it is accomplished?
  8. Compare the prince, as described by Machiavelli, with the modern political boss.
  9. What is meant by the distinction between the repressive and the directive activities of the State? What are the main conditions which justify the latter?
  10. What general principle determines the obligation of the State in the imposition of taxes?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University, Examination Papers 1873-1915. Box 8, Bound volume: Examination Papers, 1906-07; Papers Set for Final Examinations in History, Government, Economics,…,Music in Harvard College (June, 1906), p. 30.

Image Source: Portrait of Thomas Nixon Carver, colorized by Economics in the Rear-view Mirror, from the Harvard Class Album 1906.

Categories
Economists Harvard

Harvard. Graduate student teaching assistant, A.M. but no Ph.D. Frank Richardson Mason, 1906

Not all graduate students complete the requirements for a Ph.D. and, early in the 20th century, it was quite common for the Master’s degree to be the terminal degree and not all career paths lead to economics education and/or research. From time to time your curator of Economics in the Rear-view Mirror stumbles upon career information of the one or other graduate student of economics who left the formal study of economics for that so-called real world and the information is added as a biographical post. 

Here we feature two reports from the Harvard Class of 1905 graduate (summa cum laude), Frank Richardson Mason. A trace of his academic life was encountered in the previous post that dealt with the Principles of Economics course taught at Harvard in 1905-06.  Earlier we found mention of his Special Examination for the Ph.D. that was scheduled for May 14, 1908. Presumably something must have wrong in his special examination, because he looked to be on track for a Ph.D., having passed his general examinations and published a paper on his thesis topic in the Quarterly Journal of Economics.

_______________________________

From the Class of 1905
Twenty-fifth Reunion (1930)

FRANK RICHARDSON MASON

BORN: Hebron, Ill., Oct. 6, 1882. PARENTS: Ralph Nathaniel Mason, Helen May Richardson.

PREPARED AT: John Marshall High School, Chicago, Ill.

IN COLLEGE: 1901-1905. DEGREES: A.B. summa cum laude 1905; A.M. 1906.

MARRIED: Jennie Louise Barr, Chicago, Ill., Sept. 25, 1912. CHILDREN: Alfred Barr, Sept. 5, 1914; Jennie Louise, Oct. 19, 1917; Donald Frank, March 17, 1926.

OCCUPATION: Accountant.

ADDRESSEs: (home) 1124 No. Harvey Ave., Oak Park, Ill.; (business) 10 So. LaSalle St., Chicago, Ill.

For three years after graduating I was in the Graduate School, where I held a teaching fellowship, specializing in economics. For two years I was secretary of Northwestern University School of Commerce, and since then have been in various business positions. For seven years, 1912 to 1919, I was office manager for J. W. Butler Paper Company, in Chicago. For the past several years I have been a public accountant on my own, operating under the firm name of F. R. Mason & Co.

My life has been singularly free from either high lights or shadows. Outside of one trip to Europe before the war, I have had no mad adventures. My chief preoccupation has been raising a family. I meet the Chicago boys of our class about once a month, and so keep in vicarious touch with the past and present glories of our Alma Mater.

PUBLICATIONS: “The Silk Industry in the United States,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1908; “Business Organization and Principles,” (Cree Pub. Co., 1910); various translations from French and German.

MEMBER OF: Harvard Club, Chicago, Ill.

Source: Harvard Class of 1905, Twenty-Fifth Anniversary Report (June, 1930), pp. 410-11.

_______________________________

From the Class of 1905
Thirtieth Reunion (1935)

FRANK RICHARDSON MASON has spent the last five years “accounting, and getting clients out of trouble when Uncle Sam thinks they’ve ‘rationalized’ on their income tax” During this time he has performed the following public service: “gone to one Phi Beta Kappa dinner and stuck it out to the bitter end; contributed generously to Samuel Insull’s total of defalcation.” He has also written several diatribes condemning the new dealers for not paying the swatters for the home runs they didn’t make, and has spent a good deal of time standing on his head to see if he can’t make the new deal look right side up. His chief aversion is “The guy with one idea which will solve the world’s problems.” But he adds seriously, “After a life of frugal toil, having accumulated a few thousands by diligence and self denial, I have lost everything — except faith, hope, and charity.

Faith — that the American people will rise with the strength of their own backbone out of the Slough of Despond in which they have been wallowing for the past five years; Hope — that there are greater horizons further on than those we have already seen, and that dauntless souls will forge ahead to call us on to the visions discernible from the new heights; Charity — for the loud-mouthed demagogues continually shouting a rallying cry for every mirage that shimmers over the barren desert of our economic outlook. I still have Faith, Hope, and Charity, and I agree with St. Paul, the greatest of these is Charity.” Address: 10 South La Salle Street, Chicago, Ill.

Source:  Harvard Class of 1905, Thirtieth Anniversary Report (June, 1935),  p. 91.

_______________________________

Frank Richardson Mason died Jan 22, 1953 in Oak Park, Illinois.

Source: Find-a-grave website.

_______________________________

Image Source: Frank Richardson Mason’s 1905 Class Album picture and his twenty-fifth reunion portrait.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Principles

Harvard. Principles of Economics Exam. Taussig et al., 1905-1906

Over the next couple of weeks Economics in the Rear-view Mirror will be posting the printed economics course exams from Harvard for the academic year 1905-06.  Economics in the Rear-View Mirror has already transcribed and posted nearly every economics exam at Harvard University up to this year. You will find links to them in the Catalogue of Artifacts, then use page search for, e.g.,”Exam” to be awed if not shocked by the sheer quantity of material available to you.

________________________

Course Enrollment

Economics 1. Professor [Frank William] Taussig and Asst. Professor [Abram Piatt] Andrew, assisted by Messrs. [Silas Wilder] Howland, [Chester Whitney] Wright, [Seldon Osgood] Martin, [William Hyde] Price, [Frank Richardson] Mason, and [Stuart] Daggett. — Principles of Economics.

Total 470: 1 Graduate, 9 Seniors, 87 Juniors, 266 Sophomores, 63 Freshmen, 44 Others.

Source: Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1905-1906, p. 72.

________________________

ECONOMICS 1
Mid-year Examination, 1905-06

Arrange your answers strictly in the order of the questions.
Answer nine questions, five from Group I, four from Group II.

Group I

  1. Which of the following would you class as capital:—
    1. stocks of goods in retailers’ hands;
    2. a theatre:
    3. the skill, acquired through training and education, of highly efficient workmen;
    4. agricultural land permanently improved by drainage, embankments and the like.
  2. Explain concisely,
    1. the law of diminishing returns;
    2. intensive and extensive margin of cultivation;
    3. marginal utility.
  3. Suppose all agricultural land to be equally fertile and equally distant from the market; suppose all to be under cultivation: would there be rent? If so, why and where? if not, why not?
  4. Explain in what way the value of monopolized commodities is influenced on the one hand by cost of production, on the other hand by marginal utility.
  5. Explain in what way the value of commodities produced at joint cost is influenced on the one hand by cost of production, on the other hand by marginal utility.
  6. State two different ways in which expense of education and training affects variations of wages in different occupations.

Group II

  1. “The extra gains which any producer or dealer obtains through superior talents for business, or superior business arrangements, are very much of a similar kind [to rent]. . . . All advantages, in fact, which one competitor has over another, whether natural or acquired, whether personal or the result of social arrangements, bring the commodity, so far, into the Third Class, and assimilate the possessor of the advantage to a receiver of rent.” —Mill.
    Explain what is the “third class” of commodities here referred to by Mill; wherein “personal” advantages differ from those which are “the result of social arrangements”; and how far the general doctrine set forth in this extract is found also in Walker and in Seager.
  2. State concisely the residual theory of distribution, as set forth by Walker.
  3. Suppose the number of laborers to increase greatly, the other factors in production (capital, land) remaining unchanged: what changes in wages would ensue, and in what manner would they be brought about, according to Mill? Walker? Seager?
  4. Explain concisely,
    1. the capitalization of rent;
    2. the capitalization of monopoly profits;
    3. the statement that the rate of interest determines the value of land and securities;
    4. innocent investors and acquired rights.
  5. A corporation organized to do a mercantile business buys an expensive city site, erects a building thereon, carries on the operations of buying and selling, and in due time distributes dividends among its stockholders. What is the nature of the return received by the stockholders?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University. Mid-year Examinations, 1852-1943. Box 7, Bound Volume: Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1905-06.

________________________

ECONOMICS 1
Year-end Examination, 1905-06

Omit one question from each group.

I.

  1. Define capital, and mention two articles of wealth which are always capital, two which never are, and two which sometimes are and sometimes are not.
  2. Under what conditions would there be no economic rent?
  3. Explain briefly the salient influences which will determine the value (1) at any given moment, (2) in the long run, of the following:
    1. an uncopyrighted book,
    2. a copyrighted book,
    3. an ounce of gold.
  4. What are the limits to the price-fixing and profit-earning powers of monopolies? Are there any other conditions which will tend to check the indefinite growth of combinations?

II.

  1. Is it true of all commodities that changes in supply affect their value proportionally? Is it true of the commodity money? If in your opinion there is any difference, explain it.
  2. Can a commodity change its value without changing its price? Can it change its price without changing its value? Suppose the commodity were gold bullion, would your answer vary?
  3. Suppose an increase in the volume of our currency, due to a new issue of silver, what would be the effect upon international trade? Would this effect be lasting? Would your answer depend at all upon the condition of our currency at the time the increase occurred?
  4. If the merchandise imports from England to the United States equalled the exports from the United States to England (a) what would be the state of exchange on London? (b) Would there be any greater advantage to either of the countries engaged in trade?

III.

  1. Would a tariff “for revenue only” differ from a protective tariff, the product of which is entirely devoted to revenue? Has either any advantage over the other?
  2. “A man is of all sorts of luggage the most difficult to be transported.” What is the bearing of this fact upon the theory of international trade?
  3. (a) How are loans affected when the reserve limit (as established either by law or custom) is reached in England, Germany, and in the United States?
    (b) Show whether a system of “combined reserves” is needed in France, England, or Germany.
  4. Arrange the following items in their proper order as they would appear in the statement of a national bank. What criticisms would a bank examiner make? Would these criticisms vary if the bank were situated in New York, Boston, or the town of Lexington?
Loans,

360 thousands of dollars

Capital,

50      “                “       “

Reserve,

50      “                “       “

Real estate,

28      “                “       “

Deposits,

300    “                “       “

Undivided profits,

3        “                “       “

Notes,

115    “                “       “

Other assets,

20      “                “       “

Bonds and stocks,

40      “                “       “

Surplus,

30      “                “       “

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard University, Examination Papers 1873-1915. Box 8, Bound volume: Examination Papers, 1906-07Papers Set for Final Examinations in History, Government, Economics,…,Music in Harvard College (June, 1906), pp. 26-27.

Image Source: Portrait of Professor Frank W. Taussig in the Harvard Class Album 1906.

Categories
Columbia Funny Business

Columbia. Fairy tale by economics PhD alumnus (1953), Thomas Mayer

The monetary economist whose methodological contributions will likely be read long after the heated debates about monetarism lie cold in university archives or buried in the footnotes of historians of economics, Thomas Mayer, was born January 18, 1927 in Vienna. His family was able to leave Austria in the late 1930s which gave him the opportunity to go to college (Queens) and graduate school (Columbia) in New York City. This led to a long, distinguished academic career that culminated in a professorship at the University of California, Davis. He died in Berkeley, California June 12, 2015. 

This post adds to the subcollection “Funny Business” here at Economics in the Rear-view Mirror that is dedicated to attempts at nominal and real humor by economists. At the time of the writing of the following “Fairy Tale” (est. ca. 1952-53), Thomas Mayer was probably still a doctoral candidate, or perhaps a freshly-minted Ph.D., in economics at Columbia University. Martin Bronfenbrenner thought enough of this little mimeographed paper to have kept it in his files of macroeconomic teaching materials. There is no clue there, when or how he came to have a copy of the paper. In preparing this post, I discovered that only some archival boxes away at Duke’s Economists’ papers archive there is also another copy of the “Fairy Tale” in the Thomas Mayer Papers collection.

In his brief biographical tribute to Thomas Mayer, Kevin Hoover (see below for exact citation) wrote “Tom reported that Keynes’s General Theory was perhaps the first economics book that he read while still in school in England and that he was driven to keep studying economics until he was able to understand the book – a feat that he, unlike many others, claims to have accomplished”.  My favorite lines from Hoover are the following:

[Thomas Mayer] was neither a market fundamentalist nor a government romantic, but occupied the ideologically uncomfortable middle: the left thought that he was a monetarist; the right, a Keynesian. He reported having been cast off the monetarist Shadow Open-Market Committee for left-wing deviationism.

__________________________

Tributes to Thomas Mayer

Monetarism and the Methodology of Economics, edited by Kevin D. Hoover and Steven M. Sheffrin (Edward Elgar, 1995) is a collection of 14 original essays in honour of Thomas Mayer focusing on the themes of monetarism, the transmission mechanism for monetary policy, the political economy of monetary policy and the methodology of empirical economics. Contributions by: King Banaian, Mark Blaug, Martin Bronfenbrenner, Richard C.K. Burdekin, Thomas F. Cargill, Milton Friedman, C.A.E. Goodhart, D. Wade Hands, Abraham Hirsch, Kevin D. Hoover, David Laidler, Thomas Mayer, James L. Pierce, Steven M. Sheffrin, Richard J. Sweeney, Thomas D. Willett, Wing Thye Woo.

Hoover, Kevin D. (2015). Thomas Mayer. Journal of Economic Methodology 22 (4):526-527.

__________________________

AER Membership Bio, 1974

Mayer, Thomas, academic; b. Vienna, Austria, 1927. Educ. B.A. Queens Coll., 1948; Ph.D., Columbia U., 1953. Doc. Dis. The Population Argument of the Stagnation Thesis, 1953. Fields 310, 020. Pub. Permanent Income, Wealth and Consumption, 1972; Monetary Policy in the United States, 1968; Intermediate Macroeconomics, 1972. Res. Interpretation of Interest Rate Snap-Back; Explanation of Excess Reserves in 1930’s. Prev. Pos. Vis. Assoc. Prof., U. of Calif., 1961-62, Assoc. Prof., Mich. State U., 1956-61, Asst. Prof. U. of Notre Dame, 1954-56. Cur. Pos. Prof., U. of Calif., since 1962. Address 3054 Buena Vista Way, Berkeley, CA 94708.

Source: American Economic Review (October 1974). Directory of Members, 1974, p. 262.

__________________________

A FAIRY TALE1

By Anon Ymous2

Long, long ago there lived in a far and distant country a Happy Family. They were the Natural and the Market Rate of Interest. They loved each other dearly, and had two beautiful and good children: Price Level Stability and Full Employment. The parents always stuck together, for they knew that if they should part their children would be lost.

Near their house was a big wood. It was largely unexplored, and in it there lived a fierce Giant with the terrifying name of Central Bank Policy. He was a great, big, strong man. But instead of helping the two parents to keep their children happy, he would often fight with them. He pretended to love their two children dearly, but in reality he loved his own child more. His child had a shock of golden blond hair, and was for that reason known as Goldie Standard. Sometimes this child would get sick, and then her father wanted to separate our happy family. He would try to take the mother, the Market Rate of Interest, into the wood with him to take care of Goldie Standard, and to make her well again. Of course the father, poor Natural Rate of Interest, could not follow. The two sweet children would not have had the care they needed, and would starve. Poor little Full Employment would lose her full, round cheeks, and her sister, Price Level Stability, would feel so weak that she would stumble and fall many times. But Central Bank Policy did not mind this, though he pretended to, for he loved Goldie Standard above anything in the world — even though she was often naughty, and taught little Price Level Stability many naughty tricks like climbing up and down all over the Time Series.

Since the giant Central Bank Policy would have had great difficulty in stealing dear Market Rate of Interest by himself alone, he had a group of supporters called Orthodox Economists. They were on his side, for they thought that if Goldie Standard should die there would be nobody to exercise loving care over him; then, in a fit of temper, he might start to play around with the Printing Press.

One bright day a fair prince from far away arrived in this country. His name was Prince Keynes. He was the son of the ruling house of Cambridge. He saw at once what was going on in the country. Indeed, he did not find this difficult, for he had once read a vague prophecy by a Swede that such a country existed. He soon had Tract the matter down, and decided to help the poor family, but at first he did not quite know how. He studied for a long, long time, writing down his observations in a big diary. So that the giant would not find it, he hid it in a tree (not in a pumpkin [Curator’s note: a clear reference to the “Pumpkin papers” hidden by Whittaker Chambers then revealed in the case of Alger Hiss. Very much in the news 1949-50]), and for this reason it is until this day called “Tree-t’is”. (Sorry!)

Now in watching the animals playing around, especially the bears and the bulls, Prince Keynes got an idea. He built a trap, with a Schedule like a ladder; and if you followed it down you fell into a Liquidity Preference. Now the Giant’s helpers, the Orthodox economists, did not know this, and themselves fell into it, and became All Wet. Then Prince Keynes came up and told them: “I will help you out and will tell you a great Secret, if you will help me to free the poor mother, dear Market Rate of Interest.” They agreed, and so in a low voice he told them: “Always and ever and ever, when the sun setteth and when it rises, in every land and on every sea, S equals I.”

The orthodox economists were very glad to learn this Secret, and led Prince Keynes to the place where the poor mother, dear Market Rate of Interest, was imprisoned. They were the Prince’s friends by now, and went with him wherever he went, always telling each other: S equals I. Then they visited the Giant and taught him a new Canticle our Prince had invented. It went like this:

“To keep the Economy in a boom?3
Raise the Propensities — Invest and Consume —
For the rate of interest is but the consequence
Of the amount of money and liquidity preference.
And S = I whatever you say,
Unless you use young Robertson’s “day”.
Under-employment an equilibrium can be
As during the thirties any fool could see.
Wage-cuts can never full employment quite bring;
To be sure that you know it, this ditty I sing.”

The Giant was more or less convinced by this Canticle. And in any event, Goldie Standard had been so naughty that even the lady who lived in Threadneedle Street, and loved her like a mother, did not want to have anything more to do with her.

So the Giant decided to make peace with the family; and he grew to love both children, though he preferred Full Employment to Price Level Stability. Not only did he spend [his] time in keeping the family happy, but he even persuaded an animal which had inhabited the woods with him, called Fish-Call-Policy, to join him in this enterprise. So then all lived happily ever after until the next Depression.

With apologies,4
Thomas Mayer

Columbia University

Footnotes
  1. The following is an excerpt from the author’s forthcoming magnus opium, “Economics for Every Child”.
  2. The author is Lecturer in Economics and Nursery Tales at the Progressive Progress Kindergarten, Atlantis 5. He is indebted for help and criticism to himself, who however is not to be charged with any responsibility for the following. Since consumption determines the course of production, all the responsibility rests with the reader.
  3. Just what did you expect to find down here? A definition of a boom, perhaps? You might have known that a paper like this has no sensible footnotes. Of course, if you are scholarly enough to insist on a reference, look at pages 385-403 of the General Theory, where you will find an excellent summary of its doctrines — arranged alphabetically. [Curator’s note: pages are the index of Keynes’ General Theory.]
  4. The author categorically refuses to apologize to the reader. If he has read this far it is his own fault and it serves him right, and anyone who had not read this far has no business looking at the final footnote.

Source: Duke University. David M. Rubenstein Rare Book and Manuscript Library. Economists’ Papers Archive. Martin Bronfenbrenner Papers, 1939-1995. Box 25, Folder “Teaching Materials: Macro-econ n.d.”.

Copy also in Box 1 of the Thomas Mayer Papers, also in the Economists’ Papers Archive at Duke.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard International Economics Suggested Reading

Harvard. Undergraduate International Economics. Book list and final exam. Caves, 1963-1964

While the memo to the libraries promises a full reading list for the course on international trade and finance to come as soon as possible, there was no copy of Richard Caves’ full reading list for the first semester of 1963-64 to be found with other economics course syllabi in the Harvard archives. Still the twenty items arranged in approximate order of use together with the final exam questions for the course give us a good idea of the course content.

________________________

Course Announcement

Economics 148. International Trade: Basic Facts and Policies

Half course (fall term). Tu., Th., (S.), at 12. Professor Caves

Treats such problems as the balance of payments, the dollar market, capital movements, exchange rates, exchange control, European integration and the relation of domestic and international policies.

Source: Harvard University. Faculty of Arts and Science. Courses of Instruction for Harvard and Radcliffe. Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. LX, No. 21 (September 4, 1963) p. 104.

________________________

Book list for Economics 148

September 11, 1963

To: Lamont, Radcliffe, Littauer Libraries
From: Richard E. Caves
Subject: book list for Economics 148, Fall Semester, 1963-64

The following books and other special materials which I plan to assign for Economics 148 (“International Trade: Basic Facts and Policies”) are arranged in the approximate order of use during the term. Heavy assignments will be made in those titles preceded by an asterisk; in general, only relatively short passages will be assigned from other titles.

Students will be urged to purchase as a basic text Charles P. Kindleberger, International Economics, 3rd ed. (Homewood, Ill.: Richard 3 D. Irwin, 1963). I expect an enrollment in the course about the same as last year, 90 to 100.

A full reading list will follow as soon as possible.

Lary, Hal B. Problems of the United States as World Trader and Banker. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research, 1963.

Allen, W. R., and Allen, C. L., eds. Foreign Trade and Finance: Essays in International Economic Equilibrium and Adjustment. New York: Macmillan, 1959.

Meier, Gerald M. International Trade and Development. New York: Harper and Row, 1963.

Kenen, Peter B. Giant Among Nations: Problems in United States Foreign Economic Policy. Chicago: Rand, McNally, 1963.

Daedalus, Summer and Fall numbers, 1962.

Vaccara, Beatrice N. Employment and Output in Protected Manufacturing Industries. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution, 1960.

Myrdal, Gunnar. An International Economy: Problems and Prospects. New York: Harper & Bros., 1956.

Triffin, Robert. Europe and the Money Muddle. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1957.

*Salant, Walter S. et al. The United States Balance of Payments in 1968, Washington, D.C. Brookings Institution, 1963.
[Note: Chapters 2-9 were the Reading Period assignments]

Harris, Seymour E., ed. The Dollar in Crisis. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1961.

*Factors Affecting the United States Balance of Payments, Compilation of Studies, U.S. Congress, Joint Economic Committee, Subcommittee on International Exchange and Payments, 87th Congress, 2nd session. Washington, D. C.: Government Printing Office, 1962.

Tew, Brian. International Monetary Cooperation, 1945-1956. London: Hutchinson’s University Library, 1956.

Tew, Brian, The International Monetary Fund: Its Present Role and Future Prospects. Essays in International Finance, No. 36. Princeton, N.J.: International Finance Section, Princeton University, 1961.

Machlup, Fritz. Plans for Reform of the International Monetary System, Special Papers in International Economics, No. 3. Princeton, N.J.: International Finance Section, Princeton University, 1962.

Tinbergen, Jan. Shaping the World Economy: Suggestions for an International Economic Policy. New York: Twentieth Century Fund, 1962.

Asher, Robert E. Grants, Loans, and Local Currencies: Their Role In Foreign Aid. Washington, D. C.: Brookings Institution, 1961.

Millikan, M. F., and W. W. Rostow. A Proposal: Key To An Effective Foreign Policy. New York: Harper & Bros., 1957.

Mikesell, R. F. Promoting United States Private Investment Abroad. Washington, D.C. National Planning Association, 1957.

*Balassa, Bela. The Theory of Economic Integration. Homewood, Ill.: Richard D. Irwin, 1961.

Sannwald, Rolf F., and Jacques Stohler. Economic Integration: Theoretical Assumptions and Consequences of European Integration. Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1959.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in Economics, 1895-2003. Box 8, Folder “Economics, 1963-1964”.

________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Economics 148
Final Examination
January 21, 1964

Answer question No. 1 and three of the remaining five. The answers to all questions will be weighted equally.

  1. Describe the basic model used in the Brookings report (The United States Balance of Payments in 1968) to forecast the balance of payments and evaluate its completeness and correctness in terms of international trade theory.
    (Note: Make sure that you distinguish between the structure of the model and the assumptions made about independent variables used in the model.)
  2. Do underdeveloped countries face a conflict between the “gains from trade” and the “gains from growth”?
    Discuss critically the arguments which have been advanced for the restriction of imports by developing countries, distinguishing between arguments for across-the-board restrictions and those for restricting the inflow of particular types of commodities.
  3. A country devalues its currency. Show how the price and income adjustment mechanisms respond to affect the balance of payments. Would you normally expect the balance to improve? Is it possible for no net improvement to occur, although the price effect is favorable?
  4. Discuss the elements of the “international liquidity problem.” Would the problem disappear if the United States balance of payments (miraculously) returned to equilibrium? Appraise the extent to which at least two of the proposals for dealing with the liquidity problem would solve the essential elements of that problem, as you see them.
  5. A country forms a customs union with another. Illustrate the following effects for any one traded commodity, using diagrams, and assuming that the world’s and the partner country’s supply functions are perfectly elastic, while the domestic supply and demand functions are neither perfectly elastic nor perfectly inelastic:
    1. Tariff revenue foregone
    2. Transfer from the government to the consumers
    3. Transfer from domestic producers to consumers
    4. Change in consumers’ surplus
    5. Trade creation
    6. Trade diversion
      Briefly, how might the net effect (gain or loss) of the union on the country’s welfare be measured?
  6. Can industrialized countries increase their rates of economic growth by forming customs unions? Appraise the possible gains from faster growth in the setting of Western European economies. Could some of the effects of a customs union hamper growth, either among members or in excluded countries?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Social Sciences. Final Examinations January 1964 (HUC 7000.28, vol. 150).

Image Source: Harvard Square Snowstorm, February 1964. Boston Public Library, Boston Herald-Traveler Photo Morgue Collection. Copy downloaded from the Digital Commonwealth website.